Two "prenatal protection" bills received overwhelming votes ( 77-27 and 80-24) in the Michigan House of Representatives, affording expectant women with greater protection in their most vulnerable months of pregnancy. State Sen. William VanRegenmorter, the author of one of the prenatal protection bills, moved quickly to push the bill through the senate.
VanRegenmorter introduced the legislation after reviewing the case of People v. Guthrie. In that case, Thomas Guthrie was alleged to have recklessly and carelessly driven his pickup truck across four lanes of traffic and crashed into a vehicle driven by Brenda Tucker. Tucker was at the time nine months pregnant and scheduled to deliver her baby by Cesarean section the next day.
In the impact, Tucker's abdomen was slammed into the steering wheel, causing the unborn child to bleed to death. The Wexford County Circuit Court dismissed a charge of negligent homicide against Guthrie because the unborn child was not "born alive" and therefore not a "person" under Michigan law.
If the truck had hit Brenda's car a day later, after the child had been born, the child's killer could have received a life sentence in prison. Sen. VanRegenmorter recognized the gross disparity in this sentencing, and nearly three years of work have born fruit.
"This legislation ensures justice for both mother and child in such instances," VanRegenmorter said.
Prenatal protection creates enhanced penalties when pregnant women are attacked so viciously that the unborn child is either harmed or killed.